Rated 5.0 on Google, Yelp and Avvo Free Consultation Serving clients nationwide
Rated 5.0 on Google, Yelp and AvvoFree ConsultationServing clients nationwideNo Upfront FeesAvailable 24/7

$2.75M

Car Accident Settlement Against an Electrical Contractor

Kermani LLP secured $2.75 million for a Gulf War Navy veteran after a company driver ran a stop sign in Headland, Alabama. The crash cut the nerve to his left hand, and the insurer never even answered his demand.

Start Free Review
Case at a glance

Settlement

$2,750,000

Initial offer:

$0

$0

$2.75M

recovered
Defendant

Electrical contractor

Case type

Car Accident

Location

Headland, AL

How the case went from $0 to $2.75M

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

  1. The crash

    A company driver runs a stop sign, breaking our client's arm and cutting the nerve to his hand.

  2. No answer

    The firm sends a full demand, but the insurer never responds and makes no offer.

  3. Lawsuit filed

    The firm sues in Alabama and questions the driver and the company under oath.

  4. Building damages

    Doctors testify on video and a life care plan maps out the care he will need for life.

  5. Trial set

    The court refuses to delay trial and sends the case to mediation.

  6. $2.75M settlement

    The case settles for $2.75 million, reaching deep into the company's excess insurance.

Table of contents

Kermani LLP focused on what one ignored stop sign took from our client: the use of his left hand and the work he loved. The insurer never answered his demand and made no offer, so the firm sued in Alabama, where any fault by the injured person can mean no recovery. With his doctors on video, a life care plan and trial approaching, the case settled for $2.75 million.

What the case turned on

Primary liability issue

Whether the company was responsible for its driver running a stop sign, in a state that bars recovery for any fault by the injured person

Key evidence

The police report, depositions of the driver and the company, video testimony from his doctors, and a life care plan

Primary defense

The defense fought the value of his injuries and asked the court to delay the trial

What Happened at the Stop Sign in Headland?

Our client is a Gulf War Navy veteran from south Georgia who spent his working life behind the wheel of a truck. At 50, he still loved the job and the purpose it gave him: pick up a load, drop it off, head to the next one.

On December 30, 2021, he was in a work truck in Headland, Alabama. A company vehicle ran a stop sign and pulled right in front of him, driven by a man on the job for an electrical contractor.

He was taken from the crash to a hospital in Dothan, where he stayed for four days. His left arm was broken high near the shoulder, and his left wrist was broken too.

The worst damage was the part no one could see. The broken bone had cut the main nerve in his arm. Weeks later, he still could not lift his left hand or move his fingers. Doctors call this wrist drop, because the hand hangs limp from the wrist once the nerve can no longer tell the muscles to work.

His injuries included:

  • A broken upper arm and a broken wrist on his left side
  • A cut nerve that took away the use of his left hand
  • Neck and back pain, with numbness running down his arm
  • Anxiety and post-traumatic stress after the crash

He went through four surgeries on his arm. A surgeon later said the next step would be to fuse his wrist, which could ease the pain but leave it stiff for good.

Everyday life became a one-handed life. Raking leaves takes two hands, so he had to pay someone to cut the grass and pick up the pine cones. He could no longer sleep on his left side, either. He could not go back to driving trucks. He told our team that what he missed most was having a goal every day. So he started walking every day instead, to keep his life in order.

When Is a Company Responsible for a Stop Sign Crash in Alabama?

Alabama law is clear about stop signs. Under Ala. Code § 32-5A-112, a driver must stop at the sign and wait for any traffic close enough to be a danger. The other driver broke that rule.

The company was responsible too. When an employee causes a crash while doing his job, his employer is generally responsible for the harm. That is why the claim was against the electrical contractor and its insurance, not only the driver.

But Alabama has one of the harshest rules in the country for people who get hurt. It is called contributory negligence, and it means that an injured person found even 1% at fault can recover nothing at all. Most states simply reduce the award instead. The Alabama Supreme Court has kept this rule, in Golden v. McCurry, 392 So. 2d 815 (Ala. 1980), and again in Williams v. Delta International Machinery Corp., 619 So. 2d 1330 (Ala. 1993).

Alabama also sets a high bar for punitive damages, which are extra money meant to punish a wrongdoer rather than repay a loss. Under Ala. Code § 6-11-20, they require clear and convincing proof of wantonness, meaning the driver acted with reckless or conscious disregard for other people's safety. In Ex parte Essary, 992 So. 2d 5 (Ala. 2007), the Alabama Supreme Court held that a driver who pulled out from a stop sign into another car had made an error in judgment. That is ordinary carelessness, not wantonness.

These rules are why every detail of this case mattered. The firm had to show that the crash was entirely the other driver's fault, and then prove what that crash had cost our client.

Hurt in a crash with a company vehicle? Call Kermani LLP for a free case evaluation.

Why Holding the Company Responsible Was Difficult

The insurance company went quiet. In July 2023, Kermani LLP sent a full demand with our client's medical records, and the insurer never answered it or made any offer.

Distance made the case harder as well. Our client lived in Georgia, but the crash happened in Alabama, so the case had to be fought in an Alabama court. Kermani LLP's attorneys were admitted to appear in Alabama for this case, which was first filed in Jefferson County and later moved to Tuscaloosa County.

Once the lawsuit began, the defense fought hard over what his injuries were worth. As trial got closer, it asked the court to put the case on hold and push the trial date back.

The Evidence That Became Central to the Case

The firm built the case one piece at a time:

  • The police report. The local police found that the other driver ran the stop sign.
  • Sworn testimony from the company. The firm took videotaped depositions, which is testimony given under oath before trial, from the driver and from the company's own corporate representative.
  • The doctors. His surgeons, nerve doctors and counselor gave videotaped testimony about his injuries and what lay ahead for him.
  • A life care plan. A life care planner mapped out the care, surgery and help he would need for life, and what it would cost.
  • A test jury. The firm held a focus group with 12 Alabama residents to see how real jurors might react to his story.

Together, this evidence showed what the defense did not want a jury to see. A man had lost the use of his hand and the work he loved because another driver ignored a stop sign.

The Court Order That Changed the Case

In October 2025, the court made three decisions on the same day. It dismissed the wantonness claim, which took punitive damages off the table and was a win for the defense.

But according to the court's order, it also refused the defense request to delay the trial. And it sent the case to mediation, a meeting where a neutral person helps both sides try to reach a settlement before trial.

The defense now faced a firm trial date and a jury that would meet a veteran who could no longer use his hand. The case settled soon after.

How a $0 Position Became a $2.75 Million Settlement

The negotiation history shows how far the case moved:

  • Before the lawsuit: the firm sent a full settlement demand, and the insurer never answered or made any offer.
  • Lawsuit: Kermani LLP filed suit in Alabama and took the depositions of the driver and the company.
  • Building damages: his doctors testified on video, and a life care plan put a number on his future care.
  • Trial set: the court refused to delay the trial and ordered the parties to mediation.
  • Settlement: the case settled for $2.75 million. The main policy could not cover that amount, so most of it came from a second, larger policy on top, called excess coverage.

Why the $2.75 Million Settlement Made Strategic Sense

A trial carried real risk. Under Alabama's contributory negligence rule, even a small finding of fault against our client could have left him with nothing. With punitive damages gone, everything depended on a jury putting a fair value on his injuries.

The settlement took that risk away. It reached deep into the excess coverage and gave our client money for his care, help at home and the changes his life now needs.

What This Case Shows About Car Accident Claims

One of the most important lessons from this case is that silence from an insurance company is not the end of a claim. Some insurers do not respond at all until a case has been filed and is heading toward trial.

  • Was the other driver working? If so, the company and its insurance may be responsible, and not just the driver.
  • Is there more than one policy? Businesses often carry excess coverage above their main policy, and a serious injury can reach it.
  • Which state's rules apply? A crash in Alabama follows Alabama law even if you live in another state, and Alabama's fault rule is unforgiving.

A Difficult Case and a $2.75 Million Recovery for Our Client

No financial recovery can give our client back the use of his hand or the job he loved. But it gives him and his wife security for the care ahead, and it holds the company responsible for its driver's crash.

If you were hurt by someone who ran a stop sign while on the job, Kermani LLP can help you hold the company responsible. Learn more about our car accident lawyers, and your case review is free.

Frequently Asked Questions About Car Accident Claims in Alabama

What if I was partly at fault for a car accident in Alabama?

Alabama follows contributory negligence, so if you are found even slightly at fault, you generally cannot recover anything for ordinary carelessness. The rule does not apply to wanton conduct, but wantonness is hard to prove after most crashes.

Can I sue the company, not just the driver?

Usually, yes. A company is generally responsible for a crash its employee causes while working, and its insurance, including any excess coverage, may pay the claim.

Can I get punitive damages after a car accident in Alabama?

Only with clear and convincing proof that the driver acted wantonly, under Ala. Code § 6-11-20. Courts have held that a simple mistake at a stop sign is not enough, although drunk driving or extreme speeding can be a different story.

Can I bring a case in Alabama if I live in another state?

Yes. If the crash happened in Alabama, the case is usually filed in an Alabama court and follows Alabama law. Out-of-state lawyers can be admitted to handle a single case there.

What if the driver's insurance is not enough?

A business may carry excess coverage above its main policy. Your own uninsured motorist coverage may also help when the other driver's coverage runs out.

How long do I have to file a car accident lawsuit in Alabama?

Generally two years from the date of the crash, under Ala. Code § 6-2-38. Claims against a city usually must be filed in writing within six months (Ala. Code § 11-47-23). Learn more about the statute of limitations.

Free case review.
No fee unless we win.

Tell us what happened and we'll call you back within the hour, day or night.

Clients' Choice Award
Rising star
The National trial lawyers
Gerry Spence Method
South Bay Bar Association
Consumer Attorneys association of Los Angeles