Kermani LLP focused on what the crash had really done to our client and her passenger. Fault was never the fight: the shipping company accepted it early. The fight was over value. The company offered $30,000 and treated her neck and back injuries as minor. After years of documented treatment, a statutory offer and full trial preparation, the case settled for $2.2 million: $1.2 million for our client and $1 million for her passenger.
What the case turned on
Primary liability issue
Fault was accepted. The question was what years of neck and back pain, injections and nerve procedures were worth
Key evidence
Records and testimony from the treating spine doctors, the full injection and nerve ablation history, and a 998 offer
Primary defense
Soft-tissue injuries with no fractures, no hospital stay and no surgery for the driver that should have healed
What Happened When the Freight Truck Hit Her Car?
On April 6, 2020, our client was driving her sister's car through East Los Angeles with a passenger beside her. She was 20 years old. She crossed an intersection and passed another car. Then she heard a scrape.
A large diesel freight truck had caught the side of her car. The truck did not stop. It dragged her car along with it and kept going. Her car finally broke free and spun out. The car was a total loss.
Firefighters and an ambulance came. It was the first weeks of COVID-19, and the emergency room would not take her. She went home not knowing how badly she was hurt.
In the weeks that followed, the injuries showed themselves:
- Headaches about twice a week and a possible brain injury that needed a special MRI
- Ringing in her ears and pain in her shoulders
- Neck and low back pain that would not go away
- Anxiety, mood swings and fear of falling asleep
She earned her living making deliveries. Sitting in a car and lifting bags now hurt. Her passenger was hurt too, and later needed spine surgery.
How California Values Spine Injuries After a Truck Crash
Fault was not the fight in this case. The fight was over what her injuries were worth, and California law shaped that fight in three ways.
First, a company is responsible for the careless driving of an employee who is on the job. Shipping companies such as UPS, FedEx and DHL, and the contractors that deliver for Amazon, run thousands of trucks and vans. When one of those drivers causes a crash while working, the injured person can usually make a claim against the company, not just the driver.
Second, an injured person can recover two kinds of damages. Economic damages cover medical bills and lost income. Non-economic damages cover pain, suffering, anxiety and lost enjoyment of life. California does not cap non-economic damages in vehicle crash cases.
Third, how medical bills are counted matters. In Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541, the California Supreme Court limited past medical damages to the amount actually paid or owed. But in Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics, LLC (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1266, the Court of Appeal held that an injured person who treats on a medical lien can ask the jury for the reasonable value of that care.
These rules are why proving her injuries was the entire case. The defense accepted fault but valued the case as if nothing serious had happened.
Hit by a delivery or freight truck? Call Kermani LLP for a free case evaluation.
Why Getting Full Value From the Shipping Company Was Difficult
On paper, the defense had a simple story. No broken bones. No surgery for the driver. No hospital stay. To the company, this was a sore neck and back that should have healed in a few months.
The company also had every advantage of size. It had its own claims handlers, its own settlement program and very deep insurance coverage. It could afford to wait. When the case went to court, the company and its driver both challenged the lawsuit before answering it.
The Medical Record That Became Central to the Case
Our client did not get better on her own. Her treatment shows how hard she worked to get her life back:
- Chiropractic care and physical therapy
- Trigger point injections in her neck and back
- An epidural steroid injection in her lower back
- Nerve blocks in her neck and lower back
- Radiofrequency ablation, which uses heat to quiet the nerves sending pain signals, in her neck and lower back
- Consultations with spine surgeons and a psychological evaluation
Some of those procedures were frightening. During one, her legs went numb. Before another, she struggled with anxiety. She went back anyway, because the pain left her no choice.
By the end, her medical bills topped $260,000. Her passenger's bills, including surgery, topped $390,000. Each procedure was documented by the doctors who performed it, and each one told the same story: these were not minor injuries.
The Trial Preparation That Strengthened the Claim
The case turned when Kermani LLP made clear it was ready to try it. The firm served a formal settlement offer under Code of Civil Procedure section 998. Under Civil Code section 3291, if the company rejected it and a jury later awarded more, the company would owe 10% annual interest on the judgment from the date of the offer.
The firm then prepared for an October 2023 trial in the Los Angeles County personal injury courts. It lined up our client's treating spine doctors to testify, subpoenaed the deputy who responded to the crash and readied her medical records for the jury.
The company now faced a jury that would hear from the doctors who had treated her for years, not from a claims file.
How a $30,000 Offer Became a $2.2 Million Settlement
The negotiation history shows how far the case moved:
- After the crash: the company's claims handler said fault would likely be accepted.
- Company settlement conference: at a mediation the company arranged and paid for, it offered $30,000 for our client. The firm said no.
- Lawsuit: the firm filed suit in Los Angeles County Superior Court and moved past the defense's early challenges.
- 998 offer: the firm served a formal statutory offer that shifted cost and interest risk onto the company.
- Trial set: with doctors ready to testify, the company agreed to pay $1.2 million to our client and $1 million to her passenger, a combined $2.2 million.
Why the $2.2 Million Settlement Made Strategic Sense
A jury could have awarded more. But juries can also be hard on injuries they cannot see on an X-ray, and the defense would have pointed to the lack of surgery for the driver and the lack of a hospital stay.
The settlement gave both women a certain result, without a trial. For our client, it was 40 times the company's settlement conference offer.
What This Case Shows About Truck Accident Claims
One of the most important lessons from this case is that a big company accepting fault does not mean it will pay fairly. Large shipping companies often admit the obvious and then fight hard over the value of the injuries.
- Is the injury really "minor"? Neck and back injuries without fractures can still need years of injections and nerve procedures.
- Is the care documented? Consistent treatment and records from the doctors who did the work are what a jury trusts.
- Is the case ready for trial? A 998 offer and a firm trial date are often what move a large company to pay what a case is worth.
A Difficult Case and a $2.2 Million Recovery for Two Women
No financial recovery can take away the pain these women lived with after the crash. But the settlement gives them security for the care they still need. It also holds the company responsible for a truck that dragged a car and kept going.
If you were hurt by a delivery or freight truck, Kermani LLP can help you prove what your injuries are really worth. Our California truck accident lawyers serve Los Angeles County and the rest of the state, and your case review is free.
Frequently Asked Questions About Truck Accident Claims in California
Can I sue the shipping company, not just the driver?
Usually, yes. A company is generally responsible for an employee's careless driving while the employee is working. Some delivery drivers work for contractors instead of the brand on the package, so an attorney should find out who actually employed the driver and who insured the truck.
What if the company admits fault but offers very little?
Admitting fault only settles who caused the crash. The value of your injuries is a separate question. Strong medical records, testimony from your treating doctors and a case ready for trial are what usually move the number.
Can I recover my medical bills if I treated on a lien?
Yes. Under Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics, a person who treats on a lien can ask the jury for the reasonable value of that care, even if they have health insurance. The defense can still argue that the charges are too high.
Is there a cap on pain and suffering in a California truck accident case?
No. California caps non-economic damages only in medical malpractice cases. In a truck accident case, the jury decides what is fair for pain, suffering and lost quality of life.
What if I was partly at fault for the crash?
California follows pure comparative fault (Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804). You can still recover, but your award is reduced by your share of fault.
How long do I have to file a truck accident claim in California?
Generally two years from the date of injury (Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1). If a government vehicle or employee is involved, a written claim usually must be filed within six months (Government Code section 911.2). Learn more about the statute of limitations.
What is a 998 offer?
A 998 offer is a formal settlement offer under Code of Civil Procedure section 998. If the defendant rejects it and the injured person wins more at trial, the defendant may owe 10% annual interest from the date of the offer under Civil Code section 3291, plus certain costs. It puts real pressure on a company that refuses to negotiate.